1952-55—No award
1956—Marina Orschel—Germany
1957—Gerti Daub—Germany
1958—Corine Rottschafer—Holland
1959—Pamela Searle—England
1960—Daniela Bianchi—Italy
1961—Sharon Rene Brown—USA
1962—Kim Carlton—England
1963—Marlene McKeown—Ireland
1964—Emanuela Stramana—Italy
1965—Karin Schmidt—Austria
1966—Margareta Arvidsson—Sweden
1967—Elya Calligeraki—Greece
1968—Daliborka Stojsic—Yugoslavia
1969—Carole Robinson—New Zealand
1970—Margaret Hill—Bermuda
1971—Vida Doria—Philippines
1972—Ann Roger—Belgium
1973—Maria Margareta Moran—Philippines
1974—Johanna Raunio—Finland
1975—Martha Echeverry—Colombia & Summer Bartholomew—USA (tie)
1976—Pauline Davis—England
1977—Janelle Commissiong—Trinidad/Tobago
1978—Maribel Fernandez—Costa Rica
1979—Carolyn Seaward—England
1980—Delyse Nottle—New Zealand
1981—Tina Brand—Denmark
1982—Ava Marilyn Burke—Bahamas
1983—Lolita Laure Morena—Switzerland
1984—Garbiñe Abasolo Garcia—Spain
1985—Brigitte Bergman—Holland
1986—Susanna Huckstep—Italy
1987—Patricia López Ruiz—Colombia
1988—Tracey Williams—England
1989—Karen Wenden—Australia
1990—Pasaraporn Chaimongkol—Thailand
1991—Siobhan McClafferty—Ireland
1992—María Soledad Diab—Ecudaor
1993—Eugenia Santana—Spain
1994—Minorka Mercado—Venezuela
1995—Petra Hultgren—Sweden
1996—Ailleen Damiles—Philippines
1997—Abbygale Williamson Arenas—Philippines
1998—Vladimira Hrenovcikova—Slovak Republic
1999—Brenda Liz López—Puerto Rico
2000—Helen Lindes Griffiths—Spain
2001—Denise Marie Quiñones August—Puerto Rico
2002—Isis Marie Casalduc González—Puerto Rico
2003—Carla Tricoli Rodríguez—Puerto Rico
2004—Alba Giselle Reyes Santos—Puerto Rico
2005—Gionna Jimenez Cabrera—Philippines
List by Roberto Macêdo and Dan Mcevily with files from Jimmy's Pageant Page. Thanks to José Medel Bello.