1952—Myriam Lynn—Belgium
1953—Jeanne Vaugn Thompson—Louisiana
1954—Efi Androulakaki—Greece
1955—Maribel Arrieta—El Salvador
1956—Anabel Granados—Costa Rica
1957—Mapita Mercado Cortés—Puerto Rico
1958—Tomoko Moritake—Japan
1959—Sondsi Sodsal Venijvadhava—Thailand
1960—Myint Myint May—Burma & Judy Rebecca Fletcher—Louisiana (tie)
1961—Elestheria Delutsi—Greece
1962—Sara Olimpia Frometa—Dominican Republic & Hazel Williams—Wales (tie)
1963—Grace Taylor—Scotland
1964—Jeanne Venables—California
1965—Ingrid Bethake—Germany
1966—Elizabeth Sanchez—Curaçao & Paquita Torres—Spain (tie)
1967—Lena McGarvie—Scotland
1968—Yosoy Olin—Japan
1969—Zahara Boufaden—Tunisia
1970—Hilary Anne Best—Guam
1971—Magnolia Martínez—Peru
1972—Ombayi Mutaka—Zaire
1973—Wendy Janet Robertson—Chile
1974—Anna Bjorsdóttir—Iceland
1975—Christine Mary Jackson—Trinidad/Tobago
1976—Margot Elizabeth McFarlane—Trinidad/Tobago
1977—Pamela Mercer—Canada
1978—Sophia Titus—Trinidad/Tobago
1979—Yureka Kuroda—Japan
1980—Devan Walter—Cayman Islands
1981—Linda Smith—Bahamas
1982—Maureen Theresa Lewis—Cayman Islands
1983—Abbey Scattrel Janneh—Gambia
1984—Jessica Palao—Gibraltar
1985—Lucy Carbullido Montinola—Guam
1986—Dina Reyes Salas—Guam
1987—Tatiana Reyes—Honduras
1988—Liza Marie Camacho—Guam
1989—Sharon Simons—Turks & Caicos
1990—Christiane Stocker—Germany
1991—Monique Lindsay—United States Virgin Islands
1992—Barbara Johnson—Turks & Caicos
1993—Jamilah Haruna—Ghana
1994—Barbara Kahatjipara—Namibia
1995—Toyin Raji—Nigeria
1996—Jodie McMullen—Australia
1997—Laura Csortan—Australia
1998—Asuman Krause—Turkey
1999—Monica Ferreira—Portugal
2000—Tamara Scaroni—Aruba
2001—Nakera Simms—Bahamas
2002—Merlisa Rhonda George—United States Virgin Islands
2003—Kai Davis—Antigua & Barbuda
2004—Laia Manetti—Italy
List by Roberto Macedo and Dan Mcevily with files from Jimmy's Pageant Page. Thanks to José Medel Bello.