1994: Michelle Jacobson—Manitoba
1995: Linda Davey—Surrey, British Columbia
1996: Jody Cook—Nova Scotia
1997: Gabriella Petivoky—North Vancouver, British Columbia *
—resigned, succeeded by—
Sharon Ram-Ditta—Manitoba (third runner-up)
2. Caroline Frolic—Ontario
3. Shara Forrester—Nova Scotia
4. Sharon Ram-Ditta—Manitoba
Gabriella Petivoky was asked to resign after she did a photography layout for the Hooters restaurant chain. Pageant directors felt that this was questionable behavior for the titleholder, and Ms. Petivoky was replaced by her third runner-up, Sharon Ram-Ditta. Ms. Petivoky went on to compete in the 1998 Miss Asia Pacific Pageant representing Canada.