1960: Margaret Powell
1961: Edna Dianne MacVicar (third runner-up)
1962: Susan Peters
1963: Marlene Leeson—Scotia, Ontario
1964: Jane Kmita—Regina, Saskatchewan
1965: Mary Lou Farrell—St. John’s, Newfoundland
1966: (no pageant)
1967: Marjorie Anne Schofield—Burlington, Ontario
1968: Patricia Lane
1969: Nancy Wilson—Chatham, Ontario
1970: Jacquie Perrin—Toronto, Ontario
1971: Norma Joyce Hickey—Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island (semi-finalist)
1972: (unknown)
1973: Nancy Henderson—Argyle, Manitoba
1974: Sandra Margaret “Sandy” Campbell—Leamington, Ontario
1975: Normande Jacques—Blind River, Ontario
1976: Lynn Hore
1977: Jacki Mary Dreher (Miss Friendship)
1978: Kimberly Ann Allan
1979: (unknown)
1980: Marie Rinaz
1981: Carol Donnelly
1982: Laura Claudia Gianciolo
1983: Starr Andreeff—Hamilton, Ontario
1984: Terry Lee Bailey
1985: Jennifer Frances Bruno
1986: Irene Elizabeth Vermuelen
1987: Julie Christine MacDonald
1988: Katherine Stayshyn
1989: Linda Farrell
1990: Lee Ann Bruce
1991: Robin Elizabeth Nardi—Hamilton, Ontario
1992: Lana Corwen
1993-1999: (not represented)
2000: Angeliki Lakouras—Montréal, Québec (semi-finalist)
2001: Shauna Lee-Ann Olechow—Edmonton, Alberta
2002: Alicia Victoria Altares—Longueuil, Québec
2003: Katarzyna Dziedzic—Windsor, Ontario
2004: Adelynn Rose Cupino—Surrey, British Columbia
2005: Micaela Smith—Edmonton, Alberta