1947: Margaret Marshall—Toronto, Ontario (second runner-up, preliminary swimwear winner)
1948: Betty Jean Ferguson—Halifax, Nova Scotia
1949: Margaret Lynn Munn—Toronto, Ontario (semi-finalist, preliminary talent winner)
1950: MISS AMERICA TITLE POST-DATED
1951: Margaret Elinore Bradford—London, Ontario
1952: Marjorie Alma Kelly—Courtland, Ontario
1953: Marilyn Dolores Reddick—Agincourt, Ontario
1954: Kathleen Ann Archibald—Kelowna, British Columbia
1955: Barbara Joan Markham—Cornwall, Ontario
1956: Dalyce Smith—Whitehorse, Yukon Territory
1957: Dorothy Germaine Moreau—Montréal, Québec (semi-finalist)
1958: Joan May Fitzpatrick—Windsor, Ontario
1959: Danica d'Hondt—Vancouver, British Columbia
1960: Rosemary Catherine Keenan—Rothesey, New Brunswick
1961: Iris Elaine Thurlwell—Etobicoke, Ontario (Non-Finalist Talent Award for Best Popular Singer)
1962: Connie-Gail Feller—Ottawa, Ontario
1963: Helena Marie (Nina) Holden—Esquimalt, British Columbia